Collectibles Chat Ep. 11 - Charles Riser, the first astronaut autograph forger
/Collectibles Chat with Steve Zarelli, Zarelli Space Authentication; Reviewing a Wernher von Braun autograph and discussing Charles Riser forgeries.
Collectibles Chat with Steve Zarelli, Zarelli Space Authentication; Reviewing a Wernher von Braun autograph and discussing Charles Riser forgeries.
Collectibles Chat Episode 4: Steve Zarelli, Zarelli Space Authentication; exposing traced autograph scam. What to look for to identify traced over autograph fakes.
I’ve been seeing a lot of these lately — traced autographs.
In this case, the scammer makes a high resolution inkjet copy on photo paper of an authentic signed photo. Then, they trace over the printed autograph with a marker to make it look like an original signed photo. This example also had an inkjet copy of the original COA from a well-known dealer.
Remember, there are people always thinking of dishonest, yet creative, ways to part you with your hard-earned money.
Never say never, but the odds of winning an authentic Neil Armstrong or Apollo 11 signed item for way below market value in an auction format are exceedingly low. There are way too many collectors and dealers looking for Armstrong and Apollo 11 and trolling eBay 24/7. They are not going to miss an authentic Armstrong and let it go for way below market value.
If it is in auction format, and you got it on the cheap, chances are you didn’t outsmart everyone else. Chances are it sold on the cheap because it’s a fake.
You can get a deal on the rare occasion a seller significantly underprices an item and lists it as a Buy-It-Now. Then again… there are lots of trained eyes watching and you would have to hit it shortly after it’s listed.
If it’s a low-priced Buy-It-Now and it’s been sitting there for a while… yep… chances are it’s a fake.
Here is a common reproduction signed photo of the Apollo 11 crew. The signatures are not live ink -- they are part of the photo. This was distributed in mass quantities by NASA to schools, libraries and other public institutions around the time of the mission. It exists in 8 x 10 and approximately 16 x 20 sizes.
This eBay seller is offering the reproduction signed photo for a $1,000 Buy It Now and states that he has had "a few experts check it out and verify it is authentic."
This seller has another print of the same item with identical signatures, and he assures potential buyers that "his uncle got the signatures at a show in Florida."
There are many tricks in the forger's handbook, and a traced over signature is one of them.
Here is how it works.
This practice can be deceptive, but often you can see signs of hesitation or slowness as the forger is careful to cover the printed signature. In some cases, you can still see traces of the printed signature peeking out where the forger failed to completely cover the printed signature.
Here is an example of a print of an authentically signed photo that appears to have been traced over with Sharpie. The arrows point to areas where the forger did not completely cover the printed signature.
It's been about 10 years since Harrison Schmitt, Apollo 17, conducted a paid signing at NovaSpace, and he hasn't responded to mail requests either.
For many years, Schmitt would answer his mail. Before he stopped, he would sign once a year, usually around the holiday season. In December, you would hear reports of a sudden flurry of through-the-mail successes. Looks like Harrison Schmitt is working his way through the stack from this year was the conventional wisdom.
In the past few years, prices for Harrison Schmitt signed photos have skyrocketed. You can expect to pay $400 and up for unpersonalized examples. Prime examples on NASA glossies or lithos with nice inscriptions can fetch $600 or more.
In my estimation, you have a new generation of collectors in the past decade that were not around when he was signing freely through the mail. This influx of collectors have to pay for signed items on the secondary market... something prior generations of space collectors did not have to do.
With this increase in price comes a higher risk of relatively skilled fakes. In the past several months, I have seen several examples of somewhat deceptive forgeries... the likes of which we have not seen previously.
As always, do your homework, caveat emptor and have fun collecting!
Two Jim Irwin signatures... do you know which one is authentic?
Copyright 2013 - 2024, Zarelli Space Authentication, LLC.
PO Box 1032, Ballston Lake, NY 12019
Header images courtesy of Moonpans.com. Images copyright their respective owners.